Procedural Fairness in Workplace Investigations: What Employers Need to Get Right
How employers can run a misconduct or bullying investigation that gives the employee a fair hearing and stands up if the decision is challenged.
Investigation procedures used when dealing with allegations of misconduct, bullying, or poor performance are as important as the allegations themselves. An unfair process may contribute to a dispute over dismissal, including an unfair dismissal claim. Applying procedural fairness in workplace investigations allows employers to base their decisions on facts while giving employees an opportunity to have their side of the story heard.
In Australia, procedural fairness, also known as natural justice, is not a principle aimed at ensuring a predetermined outcome by following a set of guidelines. It simply seeks to ensure fairness throughout the process.
What Does Procedural Fairness Require?
The primary idea here is simple: an employee must be aware of the allegations made against them and must be given a fair opportunity to respond before the employer makes a decision.
Section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) states that procedural considerations are relevant in determining whether a dismissal is harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. In particular, these include whether an employee was notified of the reason for their dismissal, given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to their capacity or conduct, and whether the employer unreasonably refused to allow them to have a support person present, if requested.
Therefore, an investigation process should not be treated by an employer merely as a formal process used to legitimise a previous decision. It must be conducted to establish the facts and draw conclusions based on the available evidence.
Four Steps Employers Should Follow
Conducting workplace investigations involves four key steps:
- Define the allegations: Describe the conduct being investigated and any particular date(s) involved.
- Collect evidence impartially: Conduct interviews with the individuals concerned and witnesses, and examine any supporting documentation without treating the allegations as proven.
- Provide an opportunity for the individual to respond: State the charges, give enough time to answer, and take into account any other issues that might have come up in the process.
- Make determinations and document findings: Consider all the evidence, including contradictory evidence, and give an explanation for each finding.
Maintain the findings of fact separate from the decision on discipline. Even if there is enough evidence, the action to take will depend upon the severity of the conduct, among other factors.
Common Errors That Hinder the Investigation Process
One of the most dangerous things when conducting a workplace investigation is letting assumptions shape the process. For instance, considering a manager's statement to be more credible due to their status can harm the credibility of the investigation results.
Other errors are:
- Using vague allegations that do not allow the employee to know what they are expected to respond to.
- Not investigating facts that could confirm the employee's account.
- Allowing the process to drag on for a long time without informing all parties.
- Giving confidential information to people who do not need access to it.
- Coming to a decision regarding discipline before hearing the employee's response.
A workplace investigation consultant can be useful in establishing the proper investigation process, especially if the allegations involve senior managers, multiple witnesses, or possible conflicts of interest. An independent investigation may also be necessary if the company's employees cannot be objective in the matter.
Conclusion
Fair workplace investigations require more than just obtaining statements and writing a report. The employer must be able to demonstrate that the allegations have been properly investigated, that the evidence has been taken into account, and that the employee has had an opportunity to respond.
An independent workplace investigation consultant will help if the situation is complicated or delicate. Farren McRae Workplace Lawyers and Consultants conduct investigations, review investigations, and assist with workplace disputes.

